hello world!

VA Disability Appeals Success Rate: Unveiling the Truth

Last updated: November 24, 2023

The VA disability appeals process is crucial for veterans seeking to secure their entitled benefits. Understanding this system is of utmost importance to ensure a successful outcome. One avenue within the appeals process is the higher-level review, which allows veterans to have their original VA disability claim reviewed by a senior reviewer.

This alternative can offer a faster resolution compared to traditional appeal options. Veterans need to submit a request for a VA Higher-Level Review within one year of the initial decision made on their VA disability claim.[2]. By examining the VA higher-level review success rate statistics, veterans can gain valuable insights into the potential outcomes of pursuing this path.

Key Takeaways

  • The average time for an appealed claim decision has been significantly reduced from around four years to approximately four months since the AMA's implementation.

  • Higher-level reviews are conducted without new evidence by a more experienced reviewer, as opposed to Supplemental Claims, which can include additional evidence[1].

  • Veterans must request a VA Higher-Level Review within one year of the original VA disability claim decision[2].

  • The average time from submitting a Higher-Level Review request to when it is closed is around 125 days[3].

  • Higher-Level Reviews cannot be used when new evidence is desired or after a previous Higher-Level Review has been unsuccessful.

  • According to data, it has been found that the success rate for VA Higher-Level Reviews is approximately 30%[4].

“The typical duration for a Higher-Level Review request to be processed and finalized is approximately 125 days.”

Understanding the Success Rate of VA Higher-Level Reviews

VA higher-level reviews are crucial in the appeals process for veterans seeking disability benefits. These reviews are designed to provide a fresh look at a claim, to correct any errors or misunderstandings that may have occurred during the initial decision-making process.

Several factors contribute to the outcome of a higher-level review. Let's take a closer look at these factors and how they affect the overall success rate:

Factors That Contribute to Success Rates

The success rate of higher-level reviews can vary based on several factors. Some key considerations include:

  • The strength of the evidence presented: The more compelling and well-documented the evidence is, the higher the chances of success.

  • The clarity of medical opinions: Clear and concise medical opinions from healthcare providers can significantly impact the outcome.

  • Proper documentation: Ensuring all necessary documents are included and organized can help strengthen your case.

Comparison Between Success Rates of Different Types of Appeals

While it's difficult to pinpoint an exact success rate for higher-level reviews, comparing them with other types of appeals provides some context. Generally, higher-level reviews tend to have slightly higher success rates than traditional appeals or supplemental claims[1].

It's important to note that each case is unique, and success rates can vary depending on individual circumstances. Seeking assistance from organizations like Veterans Service Organizations (VSOs) or hiring a qualified attorney can help navigate the appeals process and increase the chances of a successful outcome.

Exploring the Time and Results of VA Higher-Level Reviews

The average processing time for VA higher-level reviews can vary depending on various factors. These include the complexity of the case, the availability of medical records, and access to VBMS (Veterans Benefits Management System) data. On average, a higher-level review takes several months to complete.

  • The processing time can range from a few months to over a year.

  • Factors such as the backlog of cases and staffing levels can also impact the processing time.

  • Veterans should be prepared for potential delays in receiving a decision on their higher-level review.

Examples of Successful Outcomes from Higher-Level Reviews

Higher-level reviews have proven successful in many cases, resulting in positive outcomes for veterans. Here are some examples:

  1. Increased Disability Rating: A veteran initially receiving a low disability rating may opt for a higher-level review. This could lead to an increase in their disability rating, resulting in increased benefits and compensation.

  2. Service Connection Granted: In some cases, veterans may have been initially denied service connection for their conditions. However, through a higher-level review, new evidence or reevaluation of existing evidence may result in a service connection being granted.

  3. Retroactive Payments: If a higher-level review results in an increased disability rating or additional benefits being granted, veterans may be eligible for retroactive payments dating back to when they first filed their claim.

Impact on Veterans' Benefits and Compensation

A successful outcome from a higher-level review can have a significant impact on veterans' benefits and compensation:

  • Increased Monthly Payments: With an increased disability rating or additional benefits granted through a higher-level review, veterans may receive larger monthly payments.

  • Backpay: Retroactive payments awarded due to a successful higher-level review can provide veterans with substantial financial support.

  • Access to Healthcare Services: A higher disability rating may grant veterans access to a wider range of healthcare services and treatments.

“Getting help from organizations like Veterans Service Organizations (VSOs) or hiring a good attorney can make it easier to appeal and improve the chances of winning.”

Examining the Success Rate of VA Disability Appeals for Veterans

Many disabled veterans turn to the VA Higher-Level Review process. But what is the success rate of these appeals? Let's dive in and explore.

Statistics on overall success rates in VA disability appeals

The success rate of VA disability appeals can vary depending on several factors. However, statistics show that the overall success rate for VA Higher-Level Reviews is around 30%[4]. This means that roughly three out of every ten veterans who go through this appeals process successfully have their disability ratings increased or modified.

Differences in success rates based on specific disabilities or conditions

It's important to note that the success rate can vary based on the specific disabilities or conditions being appealed. For example, certain conditions may have higher success rates due to better documentation or medical evidence available. On the other hand, some conditions may face more challenges.

Importance of legal representation in improving success rates

Having legal representation during the appeals process can significantly improve a veteran's chances of success. Attorneys specializing in VA disability claims have an in-depth understanding of the laws and regulations governing these cases. They can help gather relevant medical evidence, analyze service records, and present a compelling argument on behalf of the veteran.

Factors Affecting Success Rates in VA Higher-Level Reviews

Several critical factors influence the success rates of VA Higher-Level Reviews. From the thoroughness of initial claims to the clarity of medical evidence, understanding these elements can be pivotal in securing a positive review outcome. Let's explore these determinants in detail.

Role of evidence and documentation in determining success rates

The success rate of VA higher-level reviews is greatly influenced by the evidence and documentation provided by the veteran. The more comprehensive and compelling the evidence, the higher the chances of a successful outcome. This includes medical and service records and other relevant documents supporting the veteran's claim.

Influence of medical opinions and expert testimonies on outcomes

Medical opinions and expert testimonies are crucial in determining the success rates of VA higher-level reviews. These opinions can provide additional insight into the veteran's condition and its impact on their ability to function. If these opinions align with the veteran's claims, it can significantly strengthen their case and increase their chances of a favorable decision.

Significance of clear and concise communication during the review process

Clear and concise communication is vital throughout the VA higher-level review process. Both veterans and reviewers must effectively convey their points to ensure a thorough understanding of each claim. Miscommunication or lack of clarity can lead to misunderstandings or misinterpretations, potentially impacting the success rate of the review.

It is important for veterans to clearly articulate their claims, providing specific details about how their disabilities affect them daily. On the other hand, reviewers must also communicate their decisions clearly, explaining why certain claims were accepted or denied.

The Impact of the Revamped AMA Appeals Process on Veterans

The revamped Appeals Modernization Act (AMA) process has significantly changed how veterans appeal their claims. This section will examine the effects of AMA on success rates for veterans' appeals and discuss the benefits and challenges of the new appeal system.

Explanation of the Revamped AMA Process

Under the Appeals Modernization Act, veterans have three options when appealing a decision: Supplemental Claim, Higher-Level Review, or Notice of Disagreement with the Board of Veterans' Appeals. These options aim to streamline and expedite the appeals process, giving veterans more control over their cases.

Analysis of Success Rates for Veterans' Appeals

Since its implementation, AMA has shown promising results in improving success rates for veterans' appeals. Many veterans have found success by utilizing one of the available options under AMA. For instance:

  • The Higher-Level Review option allows adjudicators to look fresh at a veteran's claim without considering previous decisions.

  • The Supplemental Claim option enables veterans to submit additional evidence supporting their case.

  • The Notice of Disagreement with the Board of Veterans' Appeals offers an opportunity for a hearing before a judge.

These new avenues have increased efficiency and reduced backlog within the VA system, leading to improved outcomes for many veterans seeking justice.

Benefits and Challenges Associated with the New Appeal System

While AMA brings several advantages, it also presents certain challenges that need consideration:


  • Faster resolution: By offering multiple paths for appeals, AMA expedites decision-making processes.

  • Greater transparency: Veterans can track their claims online through VA's Caseflow system.

  • Flexibility: With different appeal options available, veterans can choose what suits them best.


  • Complexity: Understanding and navigating through various appeal choices may be overwhelming for some veterans.

  • Limited retroactive benefits: Choosing certain appeal routes may limit back pay eligibility.

  • Need for legal assistance: Veterans may require guidance from veterans law attorneys to navigate the new system effectively.

Improving Your Chances in VA Disability Appeals

Navigating the VA disability appeals process can be daunting. To enhance the likelihood of a favorable outcome, understanding the intricacies of the system and preparing a robust case is essential. Here's how to improve your chances in VA disability appeals. The average time from submitting a Higher-Level Review request to when it is closed is around 125 days[3].

Gathering Strong Supporting Evidence

To increase your chances of success in a VA disability appeal, it is crucial to gather strong supporting evidence for your case. This evidence should clearly demonstrate the severity and impact of your disabilities on your daily life. Some tips for gathering strong supporting evidence include:

  • Obtaining comprehensive medical records that document the diagnosis, treatment, and prognosis of your disabilities.

  • Collecting statements from healthcare professionals who have treated or evaluated your conditions.

  • Gathering statements from family members, friends, or coworkers who can provide insight into how your disabilities affect you.

Utilizing Professional Assistance

Seeking professional assistance can greatly enhance your chances of success in a VA disability appeal. Accredited representatives or attorneys who specialize in veterans' benefits can provide valuable guidance throughout the process. They can help you navigate the complex paperwork, ensure all necessary documentation is submitted correctly, and advocate for your rights.

Communicating Effectively During a Higher-Level Review

During a higher-level review, effectively communicating the details of your case is essential. Here are some strategies to consider:

  1. Clearly articulate how each disability affects different aspects of your life.

  2. Provide specific examples and anecdotes that illustrate your challenges due to your disabilities.

  3. Use layman's terms when describing symptoms or limitations to ensure clarity.

Remember that communication plays a vital role in helping decision-makers understand the true impact of your disabilities.

Following these tips and utilizing professional assistance when needed can improve your chances of success in a VA disability appeal.


In conclusion, understanding the success rate of VA higher-level reviews is crucial for veterans navigating the appeals process. Exploring the time and results of these reviews provides valuable insights into the likelihood of a favorable outcome. Effective representation, strong evidence, and adherence to the revamped AMA appeals process can significantly impact success rates.

Read more about VA disability ratings for shoulder injuries from our blogs at Disability Help.

Do You Qualify?
Disability Evaluation
Chloe Powers
Chloe works with policymakers on behalf of Disability Help to support their work at a strategic level, ensuring the conditions are in place for creative individuals and organizations to grow, reach their potential and effect relevant, sustainable change.
Do You Qualify?
Disability Evaluation

Comments are closed.

17595 Harvard Ave. C2480-C Irvine, CA 92614
(949) 979-6850
© 2024 Disability Help. All Rights Reserved.
DMCA.com Protection Status
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram